Illinois v. Gates Supreme Court Case, Arguments, Impact

Illinois v. Gates (1983) dealt with the admissibility of evidence, particularly anonymous tips to the police. The Supreme Court applied the totality of the circumstances test instead of a rigid two-pronged test developed under previous decisions. Fast Facts: Illinois v. Gates Case Argued: October 13, 1982, March 1, 1983Decision Issued: June 8, 1983  Petitioner: State of IllinoisRespondent: Lance Gates et ux.Key Questions: Did the use by the Bloomingdale Illinois police department of anonymous letters and a police affidavit as probable cause to conduct a warrant-less search of the home and car of Lance Gates and his wife violate their Fourth and Fourteenth Amendment rights?Majority Decision: Justices Burger, White, Blackmun, Powell, Rehnquist, and OConnorDissenting: Justices Brennan, Marshall, and StevensRuling: Although previous cases had established the requirements of a two-pronged approach, the majority found for Illinois, stating that the totality—combined letter and police work producing an affidavit—could be used as probable cause.   Facts of the Case On May 3, 1978 detectives at the Police Department of Bloomingdale, Illinois received an anonymous letter. The letter alleged that  Lance and Susan Gates  were engaged in an illegal drug smuggling operation. According to the letter: Ms. Lance would leave her home in Illinois on May 3 and drive to Florida.Once in Florida, her car would be loaded with drugs.Ms. Lance would fly back to IllinoisMr. Lance would fly from Illinois to Florida a few days later and drive the car and drugs back home. The letter also alleged that Lances basement had over $100,000 in drugs. Police began to investigate the matter immediately. A detective confirmed the car registration and address of the couple. The detective also confirmed that Lance Gates had booked a flight from OHare airport in Illinois to West Palm Beach, Florida on May 5. Further surveillance from the Drug Enforcement Agency on and after May 5 revealed that Lance Gates got on the flight, got off the flight in Florida, and took a taxi to a hotel room registered in his wifes name. The couple left the hotel in a car registered to them and drove north-bound on a route towards Chicago. The detective from the Bloomingdale Police Department submitted an affidavit, notifying a judge of his observations, and attached the anonymous letter to it. A circuit court judge reviewed those documents and issued a search warrant for the Gates home and car. The police were waiting at the Gates home when they returned from Florida. Officers found 350 pounds of marijuana in the car, as well as weapons and other contraband in their home. The circuit court ruled that the affidavit and anonymous letter were insufficient to establish probable cause for police to search the car and home. The Illinois Appellate Court affirmed that decision. The Illinois Supreme Court bench was divided on the issue and the U.S. Supreme Court granted certiorari to settle the question. Constitutional Question Did the police violate the Gates Fourth and Fourteenth Amendment rights when searching their home and car? Should the court have issued a search warrant based on the anonymous letter and police observations? Arguments The arguments focused on whether or not the credibility and basis of knowledge for the anonymous letter could be established. Attorneys for the Gates argued that the anonymous letter could not be used to show probable cause because it was anonymous. The author could never be shown to be reliable, one of the key standards for a two-part test for probable cause. Attorneys arguing against the suppression of the letter maintained the opposite. The detectives affidavit in addition to the anonymous letter provided sufficient grounds for a search of the Gates home and car. The search warrant had not been improperly issued and the evidence should not be suppressed. Majority Decision In a 7 to 3 decision delivered by Justice William Rehnquist, the Supreme Court ruled that the anonymous letter and affidavit could be used to establish probable cause to issue a search warrant. The Gates constitutional rights had not been violated. The Court argued that its rulings in two previous cases, Aguilar v. Texas and Spinelli v. United States, has been misapplied. Lower courts had rigidly applied a two-pronged test from those rulings in order to assess probable cause. The test required the court to know: the veracity or reliability of the informant.the informants basis of knowledge The anonymous tip that police had received about the Gates home failed to provide that information. According to the majority opinion, a totality of the circumstances approach would better help determine when there is probable cause to issue a warrant on the basis of an anonymous tip. Justice Rehnquist wrote: [P]robable cause is a fluid concept—turning on the assessment of probabilities in particular factual contexts—not readily, or even usefully, reduced to a neat set of legal rules. Veracity, reliability, and basis of knowledge should be considerations for the court, rather than rigid guidelines. The totality of the circumstances approach, according to the majority opinion, allowed magistrates to use common sense when making probable cause determinations, rather than asking them to follow rigid guidelines that might not fit the case in front of them. In applying the totality of the circumstances test, the court found that the anonymous tip and affidavit established probable cause for a search warrant. There was a fair probability that the writer of the anonymous letter received the information from the Lance or Susan Gates or someone they trusted, according to the majority opinion. Dissenting Opinion In two separate dissenting opinions, Justices William J. Brennan, John Marshall, and John Paul Stevens argued that the totality of the circumstances approach should not be used in place of the two-prong tests in Aguilar and Spinelli. Veracity and basis of knowledge should remain the two required factors for issuing a finding of probable cause. If some of the informants claims could be proved false, the anonymous tip would fail to provide a basis of knowledge for the court. In the Gates case, detectives had no way of proving when Susan left Illinois. She also failed to take a plane from Florida to Illinois as the anonymous tip had suggested. As a result, the judge should not have determined there was probable cause to search the Gates home and car. Impact The court extended the totality of the circumstances approach to anonymous tips corroborated by police statements. Instead of solely focusing on veracity and basis of knowledge to make probable cause determinations, magistrates issuing warrants could take other common sense factors into account. This loosened restraints on courts in terms of issuing search warrants. Source Illinois v. Gates, 462 U.S. 213 (1983).

Two Major Unions in America Essay - 1440 Words

Two Major Unions in America Unions in America were created to improve the working conditions of its labor force. These labor force consisted of the men, women, and children that were employed by the owners of industry. Many unions were established in the early 1800s, but due to the widespread fear of socialism and the repression from the courts, the majority of them eventually failed. Most capitalist, at the time, felt there was no need to share with its employees the profits of their businesses (Murrin et al. 2002:685-702). Management, for the most part, paid little attention to salary and provided few, if any, safety measures and health protection for the people actually doing the work. Employees worked long hours weekly, often†¦show more content†¦Supreme Court, repeatedly found unions in violation of the Sherman Antitrust Act, even though that act had been intended to control corporations, not unions† (Murrin et al. 2002:701). Later in their careers some of these men became humanitarians. But instead of providing social reform in the work place with better wages and other benefits, they distributed large quantities of their wealth instead to colleges and libraries; now they were looked at as heroes by society. Consequently, due to abuses from employers to the people under them, laws and regulations to protect workers were established and are now enforced by the U.S. Department of Labor. These laws protect over 10 million employers and about 125 million employees (2003). As written in the Department of Labors’ General Information website, it says â€Å"In carrying out this mission, the Department administers a variety of Federal labor laws including those that guarantee workers’ rights to safe and healthful working conditions; a minimum hourly wage and overtime pay; freedom from employment discrimination; unemployment insurance; and other income support† (2003). The involvement of the federal government helped curb or eliminate conditions as those found in sweatshops and other places. These jobsites usually were where people had to put in long hours under unsafe working conditions. The Industrial Workers of the World Union (IWW), unlike the Department of Labor, is mainly concerned with the laborShow MoreRelatedWhat Major Events in the Cold War Caused Fidel Castro to Side with the Soviet Union Super Power?805 Words   |  4 PagesWhat major events in the Cold War caused Fidel Castro to side with the Soviet Union Super Power? In the 1960’s the world was largely dominated by the Cold War which was a long period of tension and hostility that only occasionally broke out into open warfare. This conflict was caused by the rivalry of two superpowers - the United States and the Soviet Union and emerged after the Second World War. Both super powers had different ideologies - the United States was a capitalist democracy, whereasRead MoreThe Cold War Essay1245 Words   |  5 Pageshad America not decided on the course of actions that it took, the possibility of there being World War three would have become reality. At this time in history there was an arm’s race between the Soviet Union and America, neither wanting to be the underdog. Fidel Castro, the Prime minister of Cuba at that time (later to become President) asked for assistance from the Soviet Union to help shield it from possible American invasion. There was a treaty between the two countries. The Soviet Union; awareRead MoreThe Civil War Wa s A Tragedy Essay1504 Words   |  7 Pagesbetween the Union and the Confederate states from the year 1861-1865. The war was a tragedy, but the battles of the American Civil War caused many changes in America and in a good way, such as the abolishment of slavery and uniting the two sides together. Slavery was the main cause, but the north and south did not agree with each other on ideas, so it sparked the beginning of a war. A devastating blow to the Union, from Brig. Gen. Pierre G.T. Beauregard of the Confederate, caused Major Robert AndersonRead MoreWhat Caused The Union Of Lose The Civil War?1139 Words   |  5 PagesWhat Caused the Union to Lose the Civil War? By Amelia E. Hicks On April 10, 1865, General Ulysses S. Grant surrendered to General Robert E. Lee of Confederate forces and delivered a farewell address to his Union soldiers, â€Å"After four years of tiring service, marked by supreme courage and commitment,† said Grant, â€Å"the Union Army has been forced to concede to overwhelming numbers and resources.† According to Grant, the Union lost the Civil War, more commonly referred to in its time as the â€Å"War ofRead MoreThe Civil War And The War1214 Words   |  5 Pagescause and convinced that the other group is unreasonable on matters of national policy. The Civil war in America broke out in 1861 and lasted for four years and then ended in 1865. This was the greatest war after the Napoleonic wars in 1815 before the beginning of the First World War that lasted between 1914-1918. The war was addressing two issues on whether the American states will remain as a union or whether the countries could secede and form independent states. Secondly the war also wanted to addressRead MoreThe Battle Of The American Civil War Essay1488 Words   |  6 Pagesbe who we are today. It all started when a missile stroked a shore. At 4:32 a.m., on April 12, 1861, a fort in Charleston, South Carolina, Fort Sumter, was bombed. Threats were made to Federal troops occupying forts in the South. Major Robert Anderson was with the Union and asked the War Department for more reinforcements. He was in command of Fort Moultrie on Sullivan Island, not too far from Charleston. Anderson’s play was to move him and his men to a more secure fort, which were either CastleRead MoreThe Battle Of Bull Run1269 Words   |  6 PagesBull Run was one of the first major battles in the United States Civil War. The battle took place on July 21st, 1861 just twenty five miles southwest of Washington D.C., which was also the center of the Union Government. This battle also convinced the Lincoln administration and the North that the Civil War would last longer than they expected and would be consisting of bloodier fights costing many more lives. The US Civil War is known as the second most deadly war America has ever experienced (behindRead MoreThe Soviet Union And World War II951 Words   |  4 PagesMyth: America defeated Nazi Germany with help from its plucky British and United States sidekick Truth: The Soviet Union defeated Hitler pretty much by itself Thesis: There was a myth saying that America has a big role in helping the Soviet Union to defeat the Nazi Germany. Without the help of America, Germany could have occupy the whole Soviet Union. In fact, the Soviet Union could defeat Germany by itself since the time the U.S. involved, the Soviet Union was almost done defeating the Nazi GermanyRead MoreTimothy Webster : The New York1706 Words   |  7 PagesNewhaven, East Sussex, United Kingdom on March 12 1822 in a town which lies at the mouth of the River Ouse in the English Channel which was a ferry port pointing to France.1 Later with his parents, Timothy Webster emigrated to the United States of America on August 1830 in hopes of finding a greater opportunity. They settled in Princeton, New Jersey, where Timothy Webster started his education. As a young man, he learned to become a machinist; however he decided to join the New York Police stationRead MoreCold War Vs. Soviet Union1465 Words   |  6 Pagesand nuclear war. In thi s paper I will analyze the main moments leading to the close of the Cold War. The moments leading up to the decision that would end the Cold War are full of tension and uncertainty. In Adzhubei’s account of his visit to America and his meeting with John F.Kennedy and other officials and journalists you can tell that there is lots of tension and as Adzhubei clearly mentions there is a lot of uncertainty about how this conflict will end. â€Å"In the United States there is now

Kindred Spirits by Emmet Cahill/Celtic Thunder free essay sample

Kindred Spirits is a song that Emmet Cahill sang while he was in Celtic Thunder. This was his first solo in the group. The song is featured on the DVD Voyage and the CD Heritage. This song is about a child losing their mother who is now joining their father in heaven. The child sings about all of the good times that they all had together especially his or her parents. The child also sings about how they are now kindred spirits together forever and to never part again. This is a song that was written by Phil Coulter who helped started Celtic Thunder and he gave it to Emmet so sing. I love this song for a few reasons. I just love the meaning of the whole song. You can also feel all of the emotion coming out of him when he sings this song. This is also the first song that I heard him sing and I just think that he sings it beautifully. We will write a custom essay sample on Kindred Spirits by Emmet Cahill/Celtic Thunder or any similar topic specifically for you Do Not WasteYour Time HIRE WRITER Only 13.90 / page